-
Reviewer statements and editorial decisions.
1Probability (“risk”) of a manuscript in this group being published compared to the probability of a manuscript in both other groups. -
Agreement among reviewers regarding recommendations on the publication of eva...
Cohen's kappa for this 3×3 cross table: 0.059 [95%-CI: −0.016–0.134], Spearman's r: 0.17 (p<0.0001). When “accept” and “accept after revision” were condensed into one variable... -
Exemplary calculation of the alternative kappa statistic as proposed by Gwet ...
Alternative chance agreement probability: e(y) = 2P1(1-P1). Approximate chance that a rater (A or B) classifies a subject into category “acceptance”. P1 = [(A1+B1)/2]/N.... -
Various measurements of reviewer agreement in three studies involving manuscr...
Positive agreement denotes agreement regarding acceptance, negative agreement refers to agreement regarding rejection of a manuscript.
